For shoppers searching for silicone baby bottles with a natural nipple, the key distinction is that these six picks vary in bottle material as well as nipple shape: only the Pigeon option is explicitly silicone-coated, while the others are plastic or glass. I’d choose the Tommee Tippee Natural Start set as the best overall starting point for its breast-like nipple design and newborn suitability. The Pigeon wide-neck bottles stand out for a silicone-coated exterior, while the Philips Avent Natural Glass set suits families who prefer glass and a larger starter assortment. The tradeoffs are handling, bottle size, set contents, and how closely a nipple’s shape and flow work for an individual baby. Read on for the full breakdown and a guide to choosing by feeding routine.
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The lineup is not made up entirely of silicone bottles: Pigeon is explicitly silicone-coated; BIBS and several Philips Avent options are plastic, and the Avent gift set is glass.
- Tommee Tippee is the broadest starting point for newborn feeding: its Natural Start set is marked 0m+ and centers on a breast-like nipple design.
- Pigeon is the material-specific pick: its silicone coating and wide neck distinguish it from the plastic and glass choices, but the 5-ounce capacity is better suited to smaller feeds.
- The Philips Avent options serve different routines: the glass gift set prioritizes material choice and a multi-bottle starter assortment, while the four-pack of 4-ounce slow-flow bottles favors simple newborn-size portions.
- Pack size and bottle capacity change the practical value: BIBS and NUK come as two-packs, while the Avent slow-flow option has four smaller bottles; compare what is included rather than assuming similar sets are interchangeable.
| BIBS Plastic Baby Bottle – 9.13 oz, 2-Pack, Ivory |  | Best for Accessory-Ready Feeding | Capacity: 9.13 oz | Pack size: 2 bottles | Color: Ivory | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Tommee Tippee Natural Start Baby Bottle Set, Breast-Like Nipples, 0m+ |  | Best for Building a Multi-Size Starter Set | Bottle sizes: 5 oz (2), 9 oz (3), and 11 oz (1) | Number of bottles: 6 | Nipple type: Breast-like silicone | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| NUK Perfect Match Natural Transition Baby Bottle, 5oz, 2-Pack |  | Best for a Simple Newborn Two-Pack | Capacity: 5 oz | Pack size: 2 bottles | Nipple material: Medical-grade silicone | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Philips Avent Natural Glass Newborn Gift Set, 5 Bottles, 2 Silicone Sleeves |  | Best Glass Starter Set | Number of bottles: 5 | Bottle sizes: 4 oz and 8 oz | Bottle material: Borosilicate glass | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Pigeon Silicone Coating Baby Bottles, Wide Neck, 5 oz, Pack of 2 |  | Best for Grip and Latch Support | Capacity: 5 oz | Pack size: 2 bottles | Bottle material: Silicone-coated glass | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Philips Avent Natural Baby Bottles, Slow Flow, 4 oz, BPA-Free, 4-Pack |  | Best for Active-Feeding Rhythm | Bottle size: 4 oz | Pack quantity: 4 bottles | Nipple flow: Slow (Flow 2) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| silicone baby bottles natural nipple | Bottle material | Capacity | Pack size | Nipple design |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BIBS Plastic Baby Bottle | BPA-free, 100% food-grade plastic | 9.13 oz | 2 bottles | — |
| Tommee Tippee Natural Start Ba | — | — | — | — |
| NUK Perfect Match Natural Tran | — | 5 oz | 2 bottles | Soft, breast-mimicking shape |
| Philips Avent Natural Glass Ne | Borosilicate glass | — | — | — |
| Pigeon Silicone Coating Baby B | Silicone-coated glass | 5 oz | 2 bottles | Soft, flexible nipple with latching curve |
| Philips Avent Natural Baby Bot | BPA-free polypropylene | — | — | Breast-shaped Natural Response nipple |
More Details on Our Top Picks
BIBS Plastic Baby Bottle – 9.13 oz, 2-Pack, Ivory
The BIBS set suits parents who want breast-like nipple options and useful formula-prep accessories in one package. It includes both medical-grade silicone and natural rubber latex nipples, giving caregivers a choice that the NUK Perfect Match two-pack does not offer. Its air-reducing valve is designed to limit swallowed air, while the milk lock and collapsible funnel can make carrying and filling bottles less messy.
Compared with the size-varied Tommee Tippee Natural Start set, BIBS offers fewer bottles and less size flexibility, but its 9.13-ounce capacity works for larger feeds. The tradeoff is that this is a plastic bottle rather than glass, and the nipple cannot go in the dishwasher or microwave. I’d choose it for its feeding accessories and nipple choice, not for a fully dishwasher-ready setup.
Pros:- Includes both medical-grade silicone and natural rubber latex nipple options.
- Air-reducing valve is designed to help limit swallowed air.
- Milk lock and collapsible funnel support less-messy storage and formula filling.
- Dishwasher-safe bottle and BPA-free, food-grade plastic.
Cons:- Nipple must be washed separately from the dishwasher-safe bottle and excluded from microwave use.
- Two-bottle set offers less size variety than the Tommee Tippee Natural Start set.
- Plastic construction may not suit buyers seeking glass.
Best for: Caregivers who want a larger plastic bottle, a choice between silicone and latex nipples, and accessories for formula preparation.
Not ideal for: Families who want glass bottles, several bottle sizes in one set, or nipples that can be washed in the dishwasher.
- Capacity:9.13 oz
- Pack size:2 bottles
- Color:Ivory
- Bottle material:BPA-free, 100% food-grade plastic
- Nipple types:Natural rubber latex and medical-grade silicone
- Compliance:European Standard EN14350
- Accessories:Spill-preventing milk lock and collapsible funnel
- Care:Bottle is dishwasher, microwave, and freezer safe; nipple excluded
Our verdict“Choose BIBS if nipple-material choice and formula-friendly accessories matter more than bottle-size variety or glass construction.”
Tommee Tippee Natural Start Baby Bottle Set, Breast-Like Nipples, 0m+
The Tommee Tippee Natural Start set is the most size-flexible choice here: it includes six bottles across 5, 9, and 11 ounces, plus travel lids and removable handles. That range can suit households stocking up for different feeding stages better than the two-size Philips Avent Natural Glass Newborn Gift Set, though Avent includes glass bottles and two nipple flow rates. Tommee Tippee’s breast-like silicone nipples have an anti-colic valve, and the set is described as leakproof, making it practical for carrying prepared feeds.
Its standout convenience is three-minute microwave self-sterilizing, which gives it a clear cleaning advantage over the BIBS set, whose nipples must be kept out of the dishwasher and microwave. The limitation is that only medium-flow nipples are included, so this is less adaptable for families who need a slower flow. I’d pick it for breadth and convenience rather than nipple-flow choice.
Pros:- Six bottles span 5-, 9-, and 11-ounce capacities.
- Breast-like silicone nipples include an anti-colic valve.
- Leakproof design and three travel lids support carrying bottles.
- Microwave self-sterilizing cycle takes three minutes.
Cons:- Only medium-flow nipples are included, which may not suit every newborn or feeding pace.
- More bottle sizes and components may be unnecessary for families wanting a compact two-bottle set.
- The supplied details do not specify bottle material.
Best for: Families setting up a bottle rotation who want several capacities, travel lids, handles, and a quick microwave sterilizing option.
Not ideal for: Caregivers seeking slow-flow nipples from the start or a glass bottle set with clearly specified flow options.
- Bottle sizes:5 oz (2), 9 oz (3), and 11 oz (1)
- Number of bottles:6
- Nipple type:Breast-like silicone
- Included nipple flow:Medium flow (2 nipples)
- Valve:Anti-colic
- Accessories:Removable bottle handles, bottle and nipple brush, and 3 travel lids
- Sterilizing:Microwave self-sterilizing in 3 minutes
- Leak protection:Leakproof design
Our verdict“Choose Tommee Tippee for a versatile, travel-ready bottle supply, but look elsewhere if slow-flow nipples or glass are priorities.”
NUK Perfect Match Natural Transition Baby Bottle, 5oz, 2-Pack
The NUK Perfect Match is a focused pick for caregivers who want a small, two-bottle setup with soft medical-grade silicone nipples. Its 5-ounce capacity fits smaller feeds, while the breast-mimicking shape and anti-colic design target a comfortable latch and smoother feeding. Compared with the Tommee Tippee Natural Start set, NUK is far more compact, but it gives up the larger capacity range, travel accessories, and multiple bottle sizes.
The source description cites a 98% acceptance rate; that figure is not a guarantee for an individual baby, so I’d treat it as context rather than a promise. The clearest drawback is limited sizing: this listing only offers 5-ounce bottles. Unlike the BIBS bottle, it also does not specify alternative nipple materials or added formula-prep accessories. I’d choose NUK for a straightforward small-feed option, not for a kit intended to cover every feeding stage.
Pros:- Soft, medical-grade silicone nipple is shaped to encourage a natural latch.
- Anti-colic design is included.
- Two 5-ounce bottles make a compact pairing.
- Simple setup avoids the extra components included with larger sets.
Cons:- Only the 5-ounce size is specified.
- No bottle material or cleaning instructions are supplied in the product data.
- Does not include the size variety and travel accessories found in the Tommee Tippee set.
Best for: Caregivers who want two compact bottles with soft silicone nipples for smaller feeds or a limited newborn bottle supply.
Not ideal for: Families who need larger-capacity bottles, multiple flow options, or accessories for travel and formula preparation.
- Capacity:5 oz
- Pack size:2 bottles
- Nipple material:Medical-grade silicone
- Nipple design:Soft, breast-mimicking shape
- Anti-colic design:Yes
- Acceptance claim:Product description states a 98% baby acceptance rate
Our verdict“Choose NUK for a compact pair of soft-nipple bottles, but skip it if you need larger capacities or a more complete feeding kit.”
Philips Avent Natural Glass Newborn Gift Set, 5 Bottles, 2 Silicone Sleeves
For buyers who prefer glass, this Philips Avent set offers five borosilicate bottles in 4- and 8-ounce sizes, with silicone sleeves for grip and added protection. Its natural-response nipples are designed for a comfortable latch and controlled flow, while anti-colic valves address a common feeding concern. Compared with the plastic BIBS bottle, Avent trades lighter handling for heat-resistant glass; compared with the Pigeon silicone-coated glass pair, it provides more bottles and two listed flow rates.
The main cost of that larger glass setup is weight and more careful handling. The included flow choices are slow and medium, so caregivers needing a different pace may need other nipples. I’d rank this ahead of smaller glass pairs for households building a newborn rotation, but below plastic options for anyone prioritizing low weight or reduced breakage risk.
Pros:- Five borosilicate glass bottles provide a ready-made rotation.
- Includes both 4- and 8-ounce capacities.
- Silicone sleeves add grip and a protective layer.
- Slow- and medium-flow natural-response nipples and anti-colic valves are included.
Cons:- Glass bottles are heavier and require more careful handling than the plastic BIBS bottle.
- Only slow and medium flow rates are specified.
- Glass can break if dropped despite the sleeves.
Best for: Families who want a multi-bottle newborn set in borosilicate glass, with sleeves and slow- and medium-flow nipple options.
Not ideal for: Caregivers who need lightweight bottles for frequent travel or want plastic bottles that are less vulnerable to breakage.
- Number of bottles:5
- Bottle sizes:4 oz and 8 oz
- Bottle material:Borosilicate glass
- Nipple type:Natural-response silicone
- Nipple flow rates:Slow flow (2) and medium flow (3)
- Sleeves:2 silicone sleeves
- Anti-colic valve:Yes
- BPA-free:Yes
Our verdict“Choose Philips Avent if you want a larger glass starter set with two capacities, and avoid it if low weight and drop resistance matter most.”
Pigeon Silicone Coating Baby Bottles, Wide Neck, 5 oz, Pack of 2
Pigeon pairs a soft, flexible silicone nipple with a silicone-coated glass bottle, making it a distinct choice for caregivers who want glass with a more protected, grippy exterior. The wide neck is intended to simplify cleaning, and the latching curve is designed to support an effective latch. Compared with the Philips Avent Natural Glass Newborn Gift Set, Pigeon offers fewer bottles and just one 5-ounce size, but its 360-degree coating gives the bottle a different handling feel.
The tradeoff is less flexibility as feeding needs change: this pack includes only Stage 1 nipples, and later stages must be purchased separately. Its glass core also remains heavier and more breakable than the BIBS plastic bottle, even with the coating. I’d favor Pigeon for a small, easy-to-clean glass pair and its nipple design, not for a complete multi-size feeding system.
Pros:- Soft, flexible nipple is designed to support natural sucking and latching.
- Wide-neck opening can make cleaning easier.
- 360-degree silicone coating adds grip and a protective layer around the glass.
- Stage 1 nipples are specified for ages 0 months and up.
Cons:- Only 5-ounce bottles and Stage 1 nipples are included.
- Later nipple stages require separate purchases.
- Glass remains heavier and more breakable than the BIBS plastic option.
Best for: Caregivers who want two small glass bottles with a full silicone coating, a wide neck, and Stage 1 nipples for newborn feeding.
Not ideal for: Families seeking multiple bottle sizes, included later-stage nipples, or a lightweight plastic bottle for travel.
- Capacity:5 oz
- Pack size:2 bottles
- Bottle material:Silicone-coated glass
- Neck type:Wide neck
- Nipple design:Soft, flexible nipple with latching curve
- Nipple stage:Stage 1
- Recommended age:0 months and up
- Coating:360-degree silicone coating
Our verdict“Choose Pigeon for a grippy, coated-glass pair with newborn Stage 1 nipples, but skip it if you need size or stage variety in the box.”
Philips Avent Natural Baby Bottles, Slow Flow, 4 oz, BPA-Free, 4-Pack
The Philips Avent Natural stands out for its nipple, which releases milk when a baby actively drinks rather than flowing continuously. That feeding pattern is a useful distinction from the Tommee Tippee Natural Start, whose breast-like nipple focuses on a familiar shape. An integrated anti-colic valve and no-drip design add practical appeal for parents managing feeds away from home, while the four-bottle pack gives caregivers several small bottles to rotate.
The tradeoff is its 4 oz capacity: it may mean more refills as an infant’s feeds grow. It is also made from BPA-free polypropylene, not silicone, so it does not fit a buyer specifically seeking an all-silicone bottle. Only slow-flow Flow 2 nipples are included, limiting flow choices without a separate purchase.
Pros:- Active-drinking nipple supports a feeding rhythm similar to breastfeeding
- Integrated anti-colic valve is designed to keep air away from the baby’s tummy
- No-drip nipple helps limit spills when carrying the bottle
- Four bottles offer several small bottles to rotate through feeds
Cons:- Polypropylene construction is not silicone
- 4 oz capacity can require frequent refills as feeds increase
- Pack includes only slow-flow Flow 2 nipples
Best for: Caregivers seeking small bottles with an active-drinking nipple and a no-drip design for early feeds or outings
Not ideal for: Buyers set on silicone bottles, or families who want larger capacity or multiple nipple flow rates in the pack
- Bottle size:4 oz
- Pack quantity:4 bottles
- Nipple flow:Slow (Flow 2)
- Bottle material:BPA-free polypropylene
- Nipple design:Breast-shaped Natural Response nipple
- Milk release:Releases milk when baby actively drinks
- Anti-colic feature:Integrated valve
- Spill control:No-drip nipple design
Our verdict“Choose this four-pack if active-drinking flow and spill control matter more than silicone construction or a larger bottle capacity.”
How We Picked
I compared the six options on the details that shape everyday feeding: nipple design and stated age or flow guidance, bottle material and handling, capacity, pack contents, and likely cleaning demands. Because the phrase “silicone baby bottles” can suggest an all-silicone bottle, I gave special attention to material accuracy: the products here include plastic and glass, and Pigeon is described as silicone-coated rather than as an entirely silicone bottle.
The ranking favors clear use cases over claims that every baby will accept a particular nipple. Tommee Tippee ranks first as a broadly approachable newborn-oriented set; Pigeon follows for shoppers specifically seeking a silicone-coated, wide-neck bottle. Philips Avent’s glass set and small slow-flow multipack earn places for distinct material and portion needs, while BIBS and NUK offer other two-pack choices whose appeal depends on their respective capacity and nipple approach. I did not treat a breast-like shape as a guarantee of easier feeding or bottle acceptance.
| silicone baby bottles natural nipple | Bottle material | Nipple design |
|---|---|---|
| BIBS Plastic Baby Bottle | BPA-free, 100% food-grade plastic | — |
| Tommee Tippee Natural Start Ba | — | — |
| NUK Perfect Match Natural Tran | — | Soft, breast-mimicking shape |
| Philips Avent Natural Glass Ne | Borosilicate glass | — |
| Pigeon Silicone Coating Baby B | Silicone-coated glass | Soft, flexible nipple with latching curve |
| Philips Avent Natural Baby Bot | BPA-free polypropylene | Breast-shaped Natural Response nipple |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Silicone Baby Bottles Natural Nipple
Before choosing, separate the qualities that are often bundled together in product descriptions: bottle material, nipple shape, and nipple flow are different decisions. A natural-shaped nipple does not guarantee that a baby will accept it, and “silicone” may describe a coating or nipple rather than the whole bottle. Use these checks to match the bottle to your feeding routine, care preferences, and the baby’s current needs.
Check What the Silicone Label Actually Describes
Product names can use “silicone” to describe a nipple, sleeve, coating, or the bottle body, so confirm the material for each part before buying. In this lineup, Pigeon is identified as having a silicone coating; the Philips Avent gift set is glass with silicone sleeves, and other listed bottles include plastic options. These constructions feel and handle differently, even when they share a soft or natural-style nipple. A common mistake is assuming a silicone sleeve makes a glass bottle unbreakable or that a silicone nipple means a silicone bottle. If you want a particular material for grip, weight, or care, check the product’s component descriptions rather than relying on the title alone.
Treat Natural Shape and Baby Acceptance as Separate Questions
“Natural” or breast-like describes a design intention, not a promise that every baby will latch comfortably or switch easily between breast and bottle. Babies can respond to nipple width, length, flexibility, and how much effort feeding takes. If your baby is already feeding well, changing several bottle features at once can make it harder to tell what helped or caused fussiness. Start with a small number of bottles when possible, then observe feeding comfort and your baby’s response before building a larger set. A natural-shaped nipple is a useful starting point, but fit is individual.
Match Flow to Feeding Needs, Not Just Age Labels
Flow labels and age guidance can help narrow choices, but they do not replace watching the baby during feeds. A slow-flow option may suit some newborn routines, while a baby who struggles to draw milk may need guidance from a pediatric clinician or feeding specialist before a change. Avoid enlarging or modifying a nipple to speed up feeding; that can make flow less predictable. If you are comparing bottles, look for clearly stated flow information and check whether replacement nipples are available in suitable stages. Consistent, comfortable feeding matters more than a label alone.
Choose Capacity Around Your Actual Feed Size
Small bottles can be convenient for newborn portions and easier to handle, but they may need replacing as feed volumes rise. Larger bottles reduce the chance of outgrowing capacity quickly, though they can feel bulky when partly filled. Pack size also changes how useful a set is: four small bottles can support a rotation, while a two-pack may suit a family that wants to try a nipple before committing to more. Think about how many feeds happen between washes and whether bottles are shared between caregivers. Capacity and pack count should match your schedule, not just the number on the package.
Compare Cleaning and Handling Across Materials
Glass, plastic, and coated bottles have different tradeoffs in weight, grip, and care. Glass may appeal to families who prefer that bottle material, but it is heavier and needs careful handling; a sleeve can add grip without changing the underlying bottle material. Plastic is generally lighter to carry, while a coating may change the feel of a bottle without making it fully silicone. Before settling on a set, check the maker’s cleaning instructions, whether parts separate easily, and which components need replacing over time. A bottle that suits your washing routine can be more useful than one chosen for a single material feature.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are all six bottles in this roundup made of silicone?
No. The list includes plastic and glass bottles as well as a bottle with a silicone coating, so the phrase “silicone baby bottles” does not describe every option here. Pigeon is the explicitly silicone-coated choice, and the Philips Avent gift set pairs glass bottles with silicone sleeves. BIBS and the listed Philips Avent slow-flow set are plastic options. If the bottle body itself must be silicone, check the full material listing before purchasing rather than relying on a natural nipple or sleeve description.
Which option makes the most sense for a newborn?
The Tommee Tippee Natural Start set is marked 0m+, making it a clear newborn-oriented option in this group. The Philips Avent 4-ounce slow-flow bottles also focus on smaller portions and a slow-flow nipple, while the 5-ounce NUK and Pigeon bottles may suit families comparing compact capacities. Age markings are a starting point, not a guarantee of fit or feeding comfort. Follow the product’s instructions and seek professional guidance if feeding is difficult or the baby is not coping well with the flow.
Can a breast-like nipple prevent bottle refusal?
No bottle shape can promise that a baby will accept it. A breast-like design may be one feature worth trying, but acceptance can also depend on nipple feel, flow, feeding position, timing, and the person offering the bottle. If the baby refuses one option, avoid assuming that buying a larger set of the same bottle will solve the issue. Trying a small quantity first can limit waste while you observe the baby’s response. For persistent feeding problems, ask a pediatric clinician or feeding specialist for tailored advice.
Should I choose glass with a sleeve or a coated bottle?
Choose based on the underlying bottle material and how you expect to handle it. The Philips Avent glass set gives you glass bottles with silicone sleeves, while Pigeon is described as silicone-coated; those are not the same construction. Glass is heavier and can break if dropped, and a sleeve does not remove that risk. A coated bottle may offer a different feel, but review its care directions and material details before deciding. If lightweight handling is your priority, compare the plastic options too.
Is a multi-bottle set better than starting with a two-pack?
A larger set can help when several caregivers need bottles or when you want bottles ready between washes, but it can be a poor first purchase if you do not yet know whether your baby accepts the nipple. A two-pack lets you try a design with less commitment, while a four- or five-bottle assortment may support a more established routine. Check whether the set includes accessories you will use and whether replacement nipples are available. Match the quantity to your washing schedule and feeding frequency instead of buying by pack size alone.
Conclusion
For the best overall starting point, I’d pick Tommee Tippee Natural Start for its newborn guidance and breast-like nipple design. For a material-specific choice, Pigeon is the standout when a silicone-coated, wide-neck bottle is the priority; for best value by bottle count, the Philips Avent four-pack offers four small slow-flow bottles, though material preferences may point elsewhere. Beginners who want an age-marked starting option can compare Tommee Tippee with the smaller Philips Avent slow-flow bottles rather than buying several designs at once. Families who prefer glass and a larger starter assortment should look at the Philips Avent Natural Glass gift set. If you want a plastic two-pack or are comparing another nipple approach, BIBS and NUK round out the choices; check capacity and material details before deciding.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
